top of page
Round Grazing Board
Sheet Pan Nachos
Sushi Cups

The White Table Blog

Wisconsin Cheese Muffin Tin Snack Tray

Three delicious Wisconsin cheeses come together to satisfy even the hungriest of snackers with this fun MUFFIN TIN SNACK TRAY - here is how to put it together!

Hey there, snack queens! Are you ready to tantalize your taste buds with a snack fit for royalty? Say hello to the

Wisconsin Cheese Muffin Tin Snack Tray – a delightful mix of cheesy goodness and sweet surprises that will make your taste buds sing!

Supplies: Muffin tin + Toothpicks


  • Mouthwatering 3-year-aged Wisconsin cheddar cheese (seriously, it's delish!)

  • Irresistible Cello Copper Kettle cheese

  • Fresh Mozzarella balls (Ciliegine)

  • Adorable tomato hearts

  • Juicy red grapes

  • Sweet Cara Cara orange slices

  • Chewy dried cranberries

  • Luxurious dried figs

  • Drizzle of honey for that extra sweetness

  • Cracked pepper water crackers for a hint of spice


Each ingredient in this snack tray recipe is carefully chosen to provide a balance of flavors, textures, and colors, creating a snack experience that is both delicious and visually stunning. From the sharpness of the aged cheddar to the sweetness of the honey, every element contributes to a snack tray that is sure to impress!

  1. Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese (3-year-aged): This aged cheddar boasts a rich, sharp flavor with a crumbly texture. Aged for three years, it develops complex flavor profiles, including nutty undertones and a slightly tangy finish. It's the star of the snack tray, providing a bold and unforgettable taste experience.

  2. Cello Copper Kettle Cheese: Crafted by Cello Cheese Company, this cheese is a masterpiece of flavor and texture. Made in copper vats to impart a unique taste, it offers a smooth and creamy texture with hints of caramelized sweetness. It adds a touch of elegance to the snack tray, complementing the other cheeses beautifully.

  3. Fresh Mozzarella Balls (Ciliegine): These bite-sized Mozzarella balls are a delightfully fresh addition to the snack tray. Made from fresh cow's milk, they have a soft, creamy texture and a mild, milky flavor. Their small size makes them perfect for skewering on toothpicks and enjoying in every bite.

  4. Tomato Hearts: These adorable heart-shaped tomato slices add a burst of color and freshness to the snack tray. Sliced from ripe tomatoes, they offer a juicy and slightly tangy flavor that balances the richness of the cheeses. Their unique shape adds a playful touch to the presentation, making them a visually appealing addition.

  5. Red Grapes: Juicy and sweet, red grapes provide a refreshing contrast to the savory cheeses. Their burst of natural sweetness pairs beautifully with the sharpness of the cheddar and the creamy texture of the Mozzarella. They add a pop of color and a burst of flavor to every bite, making them a must-have on the snack tray.

  6. Cara Cara Orange Slices: These vibrant orange slices are as beautiful as they are delicious. Cara Cara oranges are known for their sweet and tangy flavor, with hints of raspberry and cranberry undertones. Sliced into rounds, they provide a bright and citrusy element to the snack tray, balancing the richness of the cheeses with their refreshing taste.

  7. Dried Cranberries: These plump and tart cranberries are dried to perfection, offering a chewy texture and a burst of sweet-tart flavor. They add a pop of color and a hint of tanginess to the snack tray, complementing the richness of the cheeses and the sweetness of the honey. Their chewy texture adds a satisfying contrast to the other ingredients.

  8. Dried Figs: Sweet and earthy, dried figs are a luxurious addition to the snack tray. They have a dense and chewy texture, with a rich and complex flavor reminiscent of honey and caramel. Sliced into bite-sized pieces, they add a touch of indulgence to the snack tray, elevating it to gourmet status.

  9. Honey: This natural sweetener adds a luscious touch of sweetness to the snack tray. Drizzled over the cheese cubes, it enhances their flavor and adds a hint of floral complexity. Its sticky texture helps to bind the ingredients together, creating a cohesive and irresistible snack experience.

  10. Cracked Pepper Water Crackers: These crisp and flavorful crackers provide the perfect vessel for enjoying the cheeses and accompaniments. Made with cracked black pepper for a subtle kick of heat, they offer a satisfying crunch and a hint of spice. Their neutral flavor allows the cheeses and other ingredients to shine, making them the ideal accompaniment to the snack tray.


Let's get this snack party started! Grab your muffin tin and assemble your ingredients.

Slice up the Wisconsin cheddar cheese and Cello Copper Kettle cheese into perfect little cubes.

Pop a cube of each cheese into its own cozy compartment in the muffin tin.

Now, let's add some fresh Mozzarella balls – because every snack tray deserves a touch of fancy!

Get creative with your toothpicks! Skewer those adorable tomato hearts, juicy red grapes, and sweet Cara Cara orange slices and arrange them in the remaining compartments.

Sprinkle some dried cranberries and figs into any empty spaces for a burst of sweetness.

It's drizzle time! Add a generous drizzle of honey over the cheese cubes for that extra touch of decadence.

Don't forget the crackers! Serve them up on the side for the perfect crunchy complement.

Pro Tip: Save this recipe to your 'Snacks' folder for those moments when you need a quick and fabulous snack to satisfy your cravings!

Check out the full tutorial video on my Instagram Reels right HERE!


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating


As much as I love to share my recipes for FREE I do have a biz to run - I know, CRAZY, right? So I am asking for a small $5/month donation to help support Platter Girl and keep the recipes flowing! 


Brunch Table
Curry Soup
Grazing Tables
Mood Changing Salads

 Currently Craving: 


Lea Dixon Its gouda brie okay
Grazing Table.jpeg



 Air Fryer Recipes to try for dinner tonight



Mostly  Plant-Based  Platters  &  Boards 

Gorgeous Spreads for Clean Eating & Great Gatherings

bottom of page